Hulk's greatest Run
Posted 15 June 2010 - 04:24 PM
Looking back over those many years of comicdom, there are those of us here who can remember many of Hulk's ups and downs (Ivan, I'm looking at you). So, to you, who was Hulk's best author. Or, if there is a particularly well written Hulk streak that constitutes the works of many writers, name that period of Hulk's history.
Descriptions will be appreciated.
EDIT: Also, please name your opinion of Hulk's worst period/author.
Posted 15 June 2010 - 05:38 PM
Edit: Explanation!? What? Oh, fine.
Peter David made it apparent that Hulk and Banner are FAR more a part of one another than either of them want to admit. He really brought the psychological aspects of the Hulk, and Banner's father, to the forefront. He turned Betty from a shrinking violet into a strong and capable female lead. You're going to get some other answers, like Bill Mantlo and Bruce Jones, but people generally only pick other answers because Peter David is SUCH an obvious choice.
Posted 15 June 2010 - 06:07 PM
The storytelling of Joe Byrne was my favourite in the comics as it was very similar to the aforementioned series. I prefer the idea of a man with a general affliction, a cancer that he's desperate to get rid of. The Hulk genuinely ruins his life in these stories, forcing him to move on, and always be lonely. Never finding refuge or sanctity, thus making it a true curse. You don't get that in the comics, you just end up thinking ''Oh for Christ sake - Aren't you cured yet ?......you've had plenty of chances''. Stark put it best in the Planet Hulk arc (I think). He basically said that Banner WANTS to be Hulk, considering how many times he's been cured. I read that and thought......well what kind of tool would want to be the Hulk?............which in turn ebbed me away from the character.
Everything else is O.k in my opinion, providing he remains true to his character, a misunderstood, basically, gentle giant. Not a tall ,sarcastic, jackass that he has been since the Pantheon arc in most stories.
Posted 15 June 2010 - 06:50 PM
Posted 15 June 2010 - 07:25 PM
But WWHulk was, simply put, painful to read. I imagine I don't need to explain why.
I disagree with your interpretation of the Hulks character, particularly, on Stan Lee's idea. His main basis for the Hulk was the combination of Frankenstein, Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde. The idea of a man changing appearance and character. But he also made it abundantly clear that the Hulk was, at heart, a peaceful being, and it was indeed the ''puny humans'' at fault for causing his tantrums - just like Frankenstein. Over time, even that simple idea has been warped. There was a particular arc (You'll know - I won't) where the idea was that he actually craved attention, like a child, not a simple, peaceful creature.A particular scene that comes to my mind, is when Hulk lifts up an entire Tank over his head, preparing to crush some soldiers. And simply because they ignored him, he put it down and walked off. Now tell me, is that really how you imagine the Hulk ?
This all being introduced after Hulk becoming, bizarrely, more of a psychological problem than a physical one. Don't get me wrong, at first, I found that a truly inspired idea, and it was - at first - done brilliantly. But the problem was, in my opinion, and is now the case with most Marvel and DC stories ( NOT SAYING ANIME IS BETTER, JUST MY INTERPRETATION) is that they get a good idea, and completely milk the idea cow dry, making you bored and irritated. I mean honestly, can you yourself say that you weren't bored by his father/son abusive relationship ? I realise it would have been traumatic, but I don't think it should have been the excessive factor it became.
In retrospect however, I do agree with you. Hulk is an angry beast, an engine of destruction. No character (that I have seen) looks as good and almost as natural as Hulk does when he's destroying things. But I only think that works if it's someone else's fault - not his. A good story that shows this would have been when (forgive me if the name is wrong) Tyrannus takes control of Hulk, causing him to go round and literally kill people, in a blind rage (or so it seemed).
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users