You are not getting it, no Star Wars Aluminium wouldn't be affected by Allomncy. However Alomancy is known to affect every other metal it comess across. I just explained to you why aluminum is the the way it is, it's because of it's own effect within the system. These metals have no such affect know I say again it's the only exception, why it's the exceptiom is explained but you seem to ignore that. and just say we don't knw la la la la." There's only one known exception, and it's because of allomantic power as I explained. It is the exception to the rule so isn't burden of proof on you? You're the one who is claiming an exception a rule, so convince me there's an exception here. Just saying "we don't know it might not be affected", when the general rule except for one very specific exception is not a good argument.
A simple no would have sufficed.
No - I'm not ignoring that. You just said that Allomancy affects every metal it comes across. Why is it so difficult for you to understand that we do not know how the metal (i.e. Durasteel and the like) would be affected by Allomancy? The very reason is because Aluminum is an example of a possibility. Okay so it's one example of a metal with a specific effect. That alone isn't enough to dissuade the possibility of a similar effect occurring. It might not happen either of course. You claim SW's metals would have no such similar effect by the way. Okay, how do you know that? You don't. Do you also not realize that if Allomancy is indeed able to affect foreign metals outside its canon, it doesn't matter if properties aren't shared if we don't know what they will do in the first place. This is that point you do not appear to be getting. It might not appear to you as good enough an argument but in actuality it is - it's why it's ambiguous in the first friggin' place. Beside one could make the claim that attempting to use the general rule as to why it would work would not be considered a good argument given the other argument.
I'm not the one who claimed the metal would be affected in the first place. Besides I've clarified what I've said several times now. -.-