10 replies to this topic

[Redwallfan2000]

Girl vs. Girl tournament

Round: 1

Match: 3

Hello and welcome to the third match of the girl vs. girl tournament. In this match up as always two girls will go head-to-head in a series of completive events. In this match up we have represnting the Cartoon Show, Teen Titans, Starfire! Whom is going head-to-head against Lust from Full Metal Alchemist so let's begin the analyses.

Starfire

Starfire was born and raised on the distant planet Tamaran before arriving on Earth and joining the Teen Titans. The Tamaraneans are an emotional race who see feelings as the force that drives their very livelihood. In fact, it's their emotions that fuel their natural abilities of flight. Because of this, Starfire is inherently the most sensitive member of the Titans. Before coming to Earth she was betrayed by her sister Blackfire and given to the Gordans as a gift which they in turn made her a slave.

Starfire had escaped from them and joined the Teen Titans after they rescued her from her captors. Starfire has the ability to fly and she can launch green bolts out of her hands, these green blast can also be formed in a sphere, she can also use them to cause explosion, even her eyes can fire green blasts, making her an extremely hard opponent to fight against in the air. Despite this Starfire also has incredible super strength, she can also fight in outer space without having to breathe in it, and survive extreme cold conditions.

One would think that Starfire's abilities make her only a threat in ranged combat, but no, Starfire has incredible super human strength as well, and has been shown to easily break threw Cinderblock's grip on her and has incredible hand-to-hand combat skills and even has immense agility. Her one and only weakness is her emotions. If she is somehow left emotionally confused, she won't be able to fly or use any of her techniques mentioned. She is also said to be allergic to metallic chromium.

Lust

Against Starfire is the Homunculus Lust the Ultimate Spear. Lust is the only female amongst the Homocli and as her name suggests her greatest ability is to turn her arms into sharp spears, which in turn she can use as weapons. These spears can pierce anything.

Due to her enticing looks and high intelligence, Lust easily and effectively plays the role of manipulator within the Homunculus ranks, moving covertly around the country to lure weak-minded people so that Father can dispose of easily, when they are no longer needed.

Lust also has high regeneration rating and easily regenerates any damage done to her. She has been shown to regenerate any damage including being incinerated by Roy Mustang but instantly regenerated although the ability to regenerate being killed is nearly considered immortal, it has it's limits and was a factor in why she had been permanently killed by Roy Mustang.

She is also slightly stronger than most humans, not to mention faster and thanks to her spear like finger nails or arms, dangerous and lethal.

Now that this is said, the contests are the same to a beauty contest, jeopardy round, and then a battle to the death.

So which of our fighters will prevail? You're votes decide.

[Callisto]

Learn More About
Starfire
Read more about Starfire at Wikipedia
Official Site: Detective Comics Links: Koriand'r's Wiki Profile Titan's Tower Profile DC Database Profile

Lust
Read more about Lust at Wikipedia
Official Site: Funimation Links: Lust Wiki FMA Warcry: Lust Lustful: a Lust fanlisting

[DamagingRob]

Don't know what the set-up's gonna be, but I know one thing; Lust can't fly...

[KibaxHinata]

In terms of beauty? Thats a tie. For jepoedy? I'd have to go with Lust, being ageless is quite an advantage in intelligence. For battle on the other hand? Lust's virtual immortality is her main advantage against Starfire. However, Starfire is faster and unless Lust can score a headshot with no problem or by sudden strikes, Starfire would be able to kill her enough time to win.

[DamagingRob]

A battle to the death... Kinda makes the previous challenges moot, no? As I said, though, Lust can't fly. Starfire could fry her ass from above, the same way Roy Mustang did.

[stargazer69]

Starfire xD. I cant take lust seriously after my encounter with that lust cosplayer...

[kwant]

there is no setup just radom facts about each character how can this be given a good grade by anyone?

[leroypowell3]

there is no setup just radom facts about each character how can this be given a good grade by anyone?

From my point of view, there was sufficient effort put into telling us what we need to know to vote. For instance, I don't know Lust at all, but in telling us about her in this sort of format, I can vote with conifidence. Although there is no story, it's not a lazy or a mistake riddled one liner or people acting out of character or a bad match up.

I'm voting for Starfire. Lust will give her a few surprises, but she will eventually be overcome.

[Callisto]

Match Final Results
USER RATINGS
A
B
B
A not a story but not a lazy set up. Now I know a little something about Lust.
SCORE
Starfire: 17
Lust: 3
FPA: 3.5

[DamagingRob]

Well, at least this bot didn't necro...

But this one did.